Private Investigator B.J. Fletcher and her best friend Georgia Drew are back in Season Two of B.J. Fletcher: Private Eye! In the opener, Fletcher and George kick start their new frequent client programme with the case of “Mrs. Lacey and her Hidden Gems”. Meanwhile, Fletcher and George attempt to adjust to some major changes in their relationship.

After their initial attempt to entrap the bicycle thieves fails, Private Investigator B.J. Fletcher (Lindy Zucker) and her associate Georgia Drew (Dana Puddicombe) track down a new lead in the case of “Mrs. Lacey and her Hidden Gems”. Fletch and George soon discover there is more to the bicycle-napping case than they first thought. Later, George and Jenna host a dinner party for the gang.

The case of “Mrs. Lacey and her Hidden Gems” continues for Private Eye B.J. Fletcher and her trusty associate Georgia Drew as they go undercover to infiltrate the local mafia. As the case continues, George worries that Fletch may be getting them in over their heads. Also, the true nature of Fletcher’s relationship with Marjorie and what happened the night George and Fletch solved the Watson case is revealed.

When the case of “Mrs. Lacey and her Hidden Gems” reaches an unexpected and shocking climax, Private Investigator B.J. Fletcher and her best friend Georgia Drew find themselves uncovering more than they bargained for. Luckily for the duo, their trusted friend Magnum offers assistance. Meanwhile, Fletcher deals with some unexpected feelings.

In the case of "Bitter Batter at the Dip 'n' Sip Bakery", Private Investigator B.J. Fletcher (Lindy Zucker) and her trusty assistant Georgia Drew (Dana Puddicombe) put technology to the test to draw out a saboteur. But when a previous case comes back to haunt them, they realize that nothing is what it seems. Later, Fletch follows up on a lead while George and Jenna take time to consider their relationship.

The plot thickens for B.J. Fletcher (Lindy Zucker) and her partner Georgia Drew (Dana Puddicombe) in the case of "Bitter Batter at the Dip ‘n’ Sip Bakery” as they race to discover the identity of the elusive saboteur. With the surprising reappearance of Fletcher's arch nemesis, Doyle (Jonathan Thomas), Fletcher and George must race to put the pieces together before the bakery is forced to close for good. When things take an unexpected turn, George enlists a reluctant Jenna (Vanessa Dunn) to help with the case.

While trying to wrap up the case of “Bitter Batter at the Dip ‘n’ Sip Bakery”, Private Investigator B.J. Fletcher (Lindy Zucker) finds herself in a frosty situation with her best friend Georgia Drew (Dana Puddicombe) and an unhappy Jenna Watson (Vanessa Dunn) after the stakeout at the bakery goes awry. Later, the long awaited lunch between George, Jenna and their Mothers (Maria Heidler and Patricia Yeatman) doesn’t quite go according to plan.

In the case of "Wheelings and Dealings at the Watson Warehouse", Private Investigator B.J. Fletcher (Lindy Zucker) and her valued assistant Georgia Drew (Dana Puddicombe) stakeout a potential mafia meeting. Jenna's concern for her mother's safety leads to a tough choice for George. Meanwhile, Fletch and George take time away from sleuthing to celebrate the holidays.

Deep in the depths of the case of “Wheelings and Dealings at the Watson Warehouse” Private investigator B.J. Fletcher (Lindy Zucker) takes her interrogation techniques to a new level in trying to ascertain the whereabouts of Doyle (Jonathan Thomas) and the stolen diamonds. Meanwhile, Magnum provides George (Dana Puddicombe) with some new insight into Fletch's history with Doyle.

In the Season Two finale of B.J. Fletcher: Private Eye, George (Dana Puddicombe) finds herself alone in a rather frightening predicament. With time running out, Private Investigator B.J. Fletcher (Lindy Zucker) and Jenna Watson (Vanessa Dunn) race to rescue George from the clutches of Doyle (Jonathan Thomas) and his mafia associates. Later, Fletcher makes a decision that could change everything.