John worries about his date with Ally and seeks for advice with the people around the office.

Harry Pippin has a near heart attack outside the court and Ally does mouth to mouth resuscitation with him. He thinks it's a kiss and almost calls off his wedding because he thinks he's in love with Ally. His fiancée talks to Ally about how she's in love with him and how Ally can have whoever she wants, and the wedding is back.

Ally has a fight in the supermarket for potato chips. She knocks out the other woman by putting her foot in her way. She's arrested by that and by stealing contraceptive gel. Ally's license is suspended because of a report that judge Boyle made on her. She has to go to a hearing and there she has to prove she's not crazy. She discovers that Whipper made the report based on Elaine's gossip. Ally isn't suspended and they all go celebrating at the bar. Ally calls home and feels that everything is allright.

Ally teaches Georgia how to drink coffee as if they were making love to it. The firm takes a big case of divorce. John's nose doesn't stop to make noises. Billy has dreams with Ally in the bathroom. She enters and starts talking to him. But he leaves and Georgia comes in and listens to Ally talking. Billy misses Ally, but she avoids him. So they decide to draw lines in their friendship. Richard takes photos of Mr. Hatfield cheating on his wife and the firm gets a settlement. Billy and Ally realize that their friendship is too important to draw any lines.

Ally has a date with a guy who leaves salad sauce on his face when he eats salad, and that drives her crazy. She has to go talk with a rabbi about a Karen's case, but she says stupid things and pisses him off. He asks Karen to leave the temple and Ally has to fix everything. She offends the rabbi again, and he asks her out. she turns him down and then asks him out.

Ally has a complex of Julie Andrews, so she and Renee make a bet on Renee's dirty joke. Ally loses the bet and has to tell a very not funny joke at the bar. She humiliates herself in front of everybody. The Rabbi comforts her and they set a date.

Ally and Renee are in sculpting class. The new model has a big penis and that drives them crazy. She runs into him in the coffee shop and he asks her out. She can't wait to sleep with him, and decides to do so, since he's leaving the country. She starts to hallucinate with a dancing baby, and John tells her to confront him, so he'll go away.

A Minister is having problems with his ex-girlfriend. She sings in the church choir and she has been singing songs related to their relationship. Ally has to solve things and accidentally finds out the real reason why Billy left her to go to Michigan: he met Georgia.

It's Christmas. Ally and Renee go on a double date with Jason, the salad dresser guy, and John. But John thinks his date is Ally and feels humiliated when he asks her on another date. Richard's uncle died and the funeral speech about how much he hated short people troubles John. The Minister doesn't want Richard to read his speech and Richard takes it to court. John feels bad about his height and Ally comforts him.

Ally runs into Glenn at the coffee shop, and he says he meant to call her. He tricks her to go on a date again. Feeling used, she decides to get back at him by humiliating him with ""The Penguin"". Billy is concerned about Ally's reputation (he's just jealous) and they have a fight, but they realize they just care about each other a lot.