We begin Season 4 with the aftermath of the post-wedding car accident. While Haley is focused on Nathan diving in to save Cooper and Rachel, the Drama Queens dive head first into the inner workings of teen relationships. The break-up of Brooke and Lucas, Peyton's perceived betrayal, and the real-life challenge of dating friends. Is it all worth it? Plus, some of OTH's most over the top storylines!

The DQ RV tour takes us to the City of Brotherly Love... or more aptly, the City of Sisterly Love. Either way the irony is thick as the discussion is all about favorite villains with none other than Dan Scott and Nanny Carrie! And even more secrets are shared ding favorite OTH moment, favorite movie, and favorite on-screen kiss! Plus some real life villainous behavior is revealed...find out which Queen once crashed a wedding!

This episode is packed full of drama and Hilarie, Sophia, and Joy are loving it even more this time around. Skills is on full display as we head back to the River Court, Moira and Barbara bring the emotion and heartbreak, the mystery pregnancy test, and Rachel goes head over heels for Nathan...uh oh! Plus a fan proposes a thrilling round of "Kiss, Marry, Slap" with Skills, Jake, and Uncle Cooper. How will it play out for each of the Drama Queens?!

Psycho Derek is in the house and he's got stories of how that nickname has plagued him for years! And Robert Buckley and Tyler Hilton return causing more chaos in only the way they can! Plus a slew of more fan questions!

It's "Good News for People who Love Bad News". Hindsight definitely proves to be 20/20 as the Drama Queens ponder why Brooke and Peyton are always at odds when it's really the fault of a boy. Hilarie, Sophia, and Joy dissect whether Nathan's behavior can be passed off simply for being Dan's son and don't even get us started on Matt Barr... This episode had great banter and amazing zingers alone but when you factor in the drama... it becomes a recap from the heavens.

It's a packed house in DC as Joy, Hilarie, and Sophia welcome close friends and special guests Antwon Tanner, Lee Norris, and a performance by Switchfoot! They reminisce about everything from being kids, to having kids and always being there for each other in between. Plus, some powerful fan questions...

As their characters struggle with the situations they're dealing with on the show... Hilarie, Sophia, and Joy relive what life was like behind the scenes during this time. It was definitely a tale of two dramas as things were surreal with the highest of highs while simultaneously marred by the lowest of lows. And it's all explained right here... Plus, a special guest performed at Tric on this episode...find out who and why this was one of Sophia's most memorable days on set!

The fun continues in 'the city that never sleeps' as Tyler and Robert join the Drama Queens! Robert and Joy do a deep dive on their mutual love of food and Sophia reveals her nostalgic secret obsession. Plus, Tyler shares the story behind the song that landed him on OTH and who it involved! Also, what's better than a potential 'Drama Kings' podcast?...you'll have to listen to find out. But trust us, it's borderline brilliant.

As Hilarie, Joy, and Sophia take a look back on the dark storyline that themed this episode, they can't help but liken it to the movie Scream. But in doing so they find some things that don't add up, which causes Joy to do an off the cuff rewrite of a memorable scene. Meanwhile, Hilarie has kind words for Psycho Derek.

Paul and Torrey join Hilarie, Sophia, and Joy as they wrap up their road trip with a Q&A live from Philly! And what better way to get comfortable for some hard hitting, thought provoking fan questions than...with a pajama party! You can go ahead and slip into your own jammies for the listen...we'll wait.

While Nathan and Haley struggle, Brooke's secret relationship and Peyton's recovery highlight the episode. It's actually Lucas rocking the 'guy-liner' that sends Joy, Hilarie, and Sophia down a path of former fashions they "pulled off" Plus, find out what parts of this episode in particular still don't quite sit right even after all these years.

The Drama Queens discuss real scandals from their own hometowns, and how they measure up to the drama at Tree Hill High. Which was more outrageous, real life or the scripts? Plus as the ladies watch parents-to-be Haley and Nathan try taking care of kids, Hilarie shares a real-life babysitting experience she'd just as soon forget about!

Q&A is back for another installment and nothing is off the table for the Drama Queens! What year of their life would they relive? What is the biggest lesson they learned from doing the show? All that plus celebrity crushes, kissing scenes, Dawson's Creek, and so much more!

It's a very OTH Holiday as Hilarie, Joy, and Sophia share their personal plans and traditions for the season. Find out which of the Drama Queens you'd be most compatible with around the holidays!

Hilarie, Joy, and Sophia recap the episode that keeps on giving...and the storylines run even deeper and with more meaning this time around. Plus, Ernest Waddell (aka Derek Sommers) joins the girls to dissect his time on the show including his instigation of Peyton and Lucas. If ever there was an episode to be thankful for, this is the one!

Peyton is smiling again and so are Hilarie, Joy, and Sophia. As they watch back this episode they see perfection... could this be the best episode yet? As they discuss how it came to be, they question how it didn't amount to more.

Lucas receives an unlikely visitor, Nathan and Dan battle guilt, and Brooke and Peyton attempt to patch up their differences. What will everyone learn? The recap of this episode gets into deep feels, as Hilarie, Joy, and Sophia admit that rewatching this one made them all fall in love with the show again.

Between Lucas' return, Haley's truth, Brooke's scheme, Dan's charges, and Deb's escape, there was a lot to unpack in this episode. But have no fear because Hilarie, Sophia, and Joy were up for the challenge (and then some!) as they go Monday Morning Quarterback on one of the most action-packed episodes of OTH!

It's another fan question episode and somehow the questions keep getting better! From never-heard-before moments from the tour, to fantasy stunt casting, to finding out the moment they all opened up to each other during filming, to which episode they'd like to go back and fix!

Elisabeth Harnois is guest co-hosting this episode. She jumps right in with both feet as she, Hilarie, and Sophia recap an episode full of betrayal and resolve. Plus, some character/actor stories mirror each other and a fan question that leaves the girls pondering an alternative to a famous storyline.

White OTH certainly had its episodes where multiple girls were in love with the same guy, we don't think there's ever been a case where three girls have fallen in love with one episode. That is...until now. Hilarie, Joy, and Sophia go head over heels for this rewatch. Find out what part of the episode they wish had happened IRL, why they want to bring it to Broadway, and what incident Hilarie and Sophia couldn't help but tease Joy about.

Looking back at this episode, certain things from the past come into new light...which may explain some of the lingering feelings the girls share. Plus, find out what was wrong with Mouth and Shelly's breakthrough scene and the girls break down the real life traits of Dan's narcissism. Get your wine ready...we're going in!

Confirmations of sex tapes and missing scenes of an important plot made for double the drama. Find out why the physical fight between Brooke and Peyton was incredibly emotional to watch back and the reason Hilarie actually hit Sophia in real life!

Find a bottle of wine that pairs well with fan Q&A and pour yourself a glass! The Drama Queens are spilling everything BUT wine as they share the secret to long-lasting friendships, parenting, a major plot line of OTH that amazingly flew under the radar. Plus, Sophia wants to give credit where credit is due for Brooke!

Psycho Derek has returned once again. Luckily this time, it's merely in the form of the man who portrayed him, Matt Barr! Thankfully he's not like Derek at all! In a silver lining, Hilarie explains how fans have come forward to share how these episodes have helped them in real life. All that plus, a secret set reveal you didn't know about and... is there a future collaboration for Matt and Sophia?!

Prom night in OTH digs up memories of prom nights IRL. AS you might anticipate they were all memorable evenings, but not necessarily for the right reasons. Plus, on set injuries you wouldn't believe and find out what moment in this episode gave the Drama Queens chills.

Imagine your favorite TV show arrives in your small hometown. That's what happened in Honey Grove, Texas when the cast and crew took the show on the road and filmed on location. The girls reminisce about the trip and it's filled with nostalgia, friendship, lasting memories, and deep emotions.

Ladies and gentlemen, your Tree Hill Ravens star basketball player, number 23...Nathan Scott! James and the Drama Queens discuss Nathan's character evolution and what it was like being only 17 years old but Nathan Scott to the world. Plus, James tackles your burning questions!

The Drama Queens break down "The Runaway Found" episode with James...and he doesn't hold back! James reveals his real opinion of the storylines, what he would have done differently if he was in charge, and what it was liking working with his on-screen son! A recap of the episode is amazing in itself, but the breakdown from Hilarie, Sophia, Joy, and James - is One Tree Hill Heaven.

The thrills continue with more fan Q&A! Find out who the Drama Queens want to join them on a dream dinner date. Plus, does one of them have a picture of a ghost?!

It's a late night recording of the pod and the wine is flowing. While Sophia, Hilarie, and Joy struggle with the drama between Dan and Lucas in this episode, they find comfort (and more!) in Nathan. Plus, find out what happened in this episode that Sophia deems so valuable that she's singing its praises 16 years later.

It’s graduation day in Tree Hill and Joy, Hilarie and Sophia are looking back and reflecting on what they’re still learning. Find out who rises as a surprising model mentor, whose humbling ended up being super hot and what moment brought everyone to tears.

It's the season 4 finale and it's a graduation party all over again as Danneel Ackles returns for this episode! There's so much to unpack here... the graduation party, Haley giving birth, and Dan facing the consequences of his actions! Plus, Sophia recalls a hilarious BTS memory with Stephen that you may need to rewind just so you can hear it again!