Chelsea and James return from their holiday break to discuss a cautionary tale about rugged dads: Hunter Hunter.

Chelsea and James are okay-ish detectives in this week’s thrilling episode! Featuring mini mysteries by author Hy Conrad, who generously gave us permission to bumble our way through his crime scenes.

Chelsea and James wonder how you can know a field is sad if there isn't a sad person in it.

No gods this week but chaos. Chelsea and James debate whether a slew of movies are even horror in the first place.

Chelsea and James journey to Lake Mungo, promptly poop their pants, and meet Bob Smeet.

Chelsea and James spread the Good Word & learn which horror movie villain has the potential to heal the left/right political divide.

Chelsea and James bring you up to speed with the history of South Sudan, which is crucial for enjoying this week (and next week's!) film, His House.

Chelsea and James finally analyze the film His House this week after last week's history lesson (highly recommended to listen to that first!)

Chelsea and James discuss Psycho Goreman and his legion of gleep glops.

Chelsea and James interview Brea Grant about her newly released film, Lucky, and talk all things 12 Hour Shift.

Chelsea and James are joined by friend of the show/guy who lives above their garage, James Graessle, to make a bunch of horror villains fight each other, ranging from "Oh yeah I've heard of that guy, I think" to "You're just making this movie up."

Chelsea and James interview Spencer Charnas of Ice Nine Kills, and talk metal subgenres, favorite horror movies, and getting banned by Disney.

Chelsea and James are AGAIN joined by friend of the show/guy who lives above their garage, James Graessle, to make a bunch of horror characters who AREN'T VILLAINS fight each other, finally finding our true champion who can solve the Mary Shaw problem.

Chelsea and James fill their hearts with so much love as overnight Reddit front-pager—and surreal final girl, Katie Adkins—joins us to discuss Too Many Cooks!

Chelsea and James have a VERY wide-ranging discussion about horror, film in general and more, with director of Mayhem and Wrong Turn 2, Joe Lynch!

Chelsea and James are joined by James Graessle to play a classic party game.

Chelsea and James are back with the impossible job of ranking all of our favorite Friday the 13th townies, cops, and people with dirt on them.

Chelsea and James discuss movie with a SPOOKY SKELETON IN IT, The Green Knight.

Chelsea and James discuss Nia DaCosta’s Candyman: its themes, its position in the canon, and how Yahya Abdul-Mateen II is extremely handsome. [Couple of corrections to make here: 1) Yahya isn't in Lovecraft Country—we didn't watch the show, and were mistaken since that was also a Monkeypaw production. 2) The puppets were done by Manual Cinema, not Kara Walker. Similar styles but different artists. Sorry!]

Chelsea tortures James this week with the second part of our favorite but absolutely impossible game show: GUESS! THE! KILL!

Chelsea and James review Malignant. [I re-wrote this episode description like ten times and cannot find the words to describe the indescribable — Chelsea]

Chelsea and James visit a movie that Chelsea had not seen until last week, because the trailer for it scared her so much—White Noise!

Chelsea and James are joined by Joey Clift to talk about the weird, magical intersection of wrestling and horror.

Chelsea and James talk about the global phenomenon that is Squid Game.

Chelsea introduces James to Predator Island, a movie she rented so often from Hollywood Video it maybe kept them solvent.

Chelsea and James are joined by their friend Johnny Berchtold, to talk about home haunts, scare school, and controversial candy.

Chelsea and James review Halloween Kills, a divisive movie we have divided feelings about.

Chelsea and James discuss all four Scream movies, from the comfort of Stu Macher's living room.

Chelsea and James are joined this week by Bonnie Aarons, to talk about *that* part of Mulholland Drive, Nun business, and the mental benefits of horror.

Chelsea and James take a well-planned shortcut through the Sierra Nevada this week and discuss 1999's Ravenous, an underrated flick with a lot of dudes covered in dirt.

Chelsea and James hit the pool one more time, to talk Paranormal Activity: Next of Kin.