Lights, camera, deception! Host Josh Peck welcomes sharp-witted horror movie buffs Rowan, Jayson, and Bobby to a bone-chilling, spooky morgue set where the line between cinematic fiction and reality blurs. The trio faces the ultimate test of perception as they attempt to spot hyperrealistic sweets hidden among Hollywood props and behind-the-scenes movie gear by master baker JonnyCakes, the viral illusionist of the baking world. After the sweets are revealed, JonnyCakes shows how he created his incredible edible illusions. If the eagle-eyed horror fans successfully dissect the truth to find all six secret sweets, they walk away with $12,000!