Gigi and Yaya plan a surprise birthday party for their uptight, anxiety-ridden friend, Ally. When Ally comes home, she is not pleased with what she sees. As the girls break into discussion on age and careers, a mysterious stranger invites herself in with a gift Ally never dreamed of receiving.

After finding out that she's a witch, a skeptical Ally tries to resume her normal day-to-day routine and head to work. However, a potential opportunity to move up in the professional ladder turns into a showcase for Ally's powers of projection when she inadvertently tries to kill her boss, Mr. Fairfax. Ally seeks refuge in a coffee shop, where she tests out her abilities of body manipulation on fellow patrons. Her fun is cut short by a visit from Ada, who encourages the sullen skeptic to embrace her newfound gifts. Chelsea pursues Ally.

Yaya's mind-reading skills are put on display when she hears the thoughts of others while riding the subway to her flower shop. Tired of being the "strong friend" to Ally and Gigi, the holistic herbalist vents to her employee and crush Coop, who has eyes for fellow co-worker Toni. Under Chelsea's command, a homeless man attacks Yaya on her train ride home. Ada seeks out Yaya to keeps tabs on Ally and Gigi.

Gigi’s dives head first. A Twitter Troll crashes the party. Unexpected tension rises between two male suitors.

Yaya brings Ally into her head. Kyle hits below the belt. Ada finally gets the floor.

Ally battles her inner witch. Yaya’s shop has a weird occurrence. Gigi’s past comes to visit.

Yaya ignores her gut. Ally catches the love bug. Ada bumps into an old friend.