Small Town Secrets

Denise Pflum left her home in rural Indiana to look for her purse in 1986. She hasn’t been seen since. The Sheriff’s department is taking a fresh look at the case — and her ex.

Two cousins have allegedly confessed to killing Denise multiple times. They’ve never been arrested, and police say one of them hasn’t even been questioned — until now.

While in custody, Denise's ex-boyfriend confesses to killing her. But he dies before the case can go to trial, leaving Connersville with more questions than answers.