Drama Queens

Look Me in the Eyeliner (4x11)

:

While Nathan and Haley struggle, Brooke's secret relationship and Peyton's recovery highlight the episode. It's actually Lucas rocking the 'guy-liner' that sends Joy, Hilarie, and Sophia down a path of former fashions they "pulled off" Plus, find out what parts of this episode in particular still don't quite sit right even after all these years.