Eli gets suspended for vandalizing school properties. At the guidance counselor’s office, he meets Nikko, the straight A student who’s feisty and assertive. From two different clocks, they get the surprise of their lives when they learned they have to dance together… at the school prom.

After agreeing to join the soiree, Eli and Nikko still have friction when dealing with each other, and Justin can’t be more upset about it. Yet, Nikko’s kindness might give Eli a change of heart.

Tension arises between Justin and Eli as they fight for Nikko's attention. But Eli takes a step back when the whole school starts to notice his closeness with Nikko. Justin is worried for Nikko, and he wants to be always on his side.

As promposals happen at Bright High left and right, Nikko and Eli becomes closer as they begin to see a new light in each other. Justin is being set aside, but he still wants to protect Nikko from anything or anyone that may harm him.

As the prom approaches, tension arises more between Eli and Justin to win over Nikko’s heart. Eli comes to term with himself when it comes to who he really wants to take to prom. Justin prepares to confess of who he wants to do the promposal.

Eli discovered something about Nikko, when Justin tells him why he insists on protecting him. They also learn that Nikko might not attend the prom, and it hurts them both. Eli discovers a way on how to become closer to Nikko.

Eli is shattered when he learned that Nikko won’t be able to go to the prom. But he learned about Nikko’s bucket list, in his No Fear list. He will make ways to make these things happen. Justin becomes more jealous.

Eli and Justin make it their mission to be there for Nikko, and are delighted when they learn that finally, Nikko is allowed by his mom to go to prom. It’s now their chance to make another promposal, to make Nikko choose between the two of them.