Roman returns home for Christmas, but John feels hurt when the family welcomes Roman with a cake, believing he's been replaced. Meanwhile, Jack struggles with jealousy as Jennifer spends time with Hawk, who takes her horseback riding. Jo counsels both Jack and Jennifer, urging them not to give up on each other.
Jack hides in the shadows when Jennifer and Hawk return to the penthouse, then decides to fight for their relationship. He purchases a new suit to feel like himself again. Jennifer, unaware of Jack's efforts, decorates Hawk's apartment and considers staying with Alice for the holidays. When Jack attempts to reach out to Jennifer on the street, a misunderstanding with a toy gun forces him to flee. Despite the obstacles, Jack remains determined to win Jennifer back.
