Roman and Abe search for Olivia, discovering she may have fled to a tropical estate owned by Rebecca's family. On the island, Orpheus holds both Olivia and Marlena captive, refusing to reveal Marlena's whereabouts.
A complicated romantic situation unfolds in New York when Kim unexpectedly encounters Shane and his new girlfriend Gillian. Paul arrives and poses as Kim's boyfriend to cover her and Shane's secret weekend together. Kim and Paul must now pretend to be a couple to convince Gillian their relationship is truly over, while Shane and Kim are forced to hide their continued connection.
At the hospital, Mike is stunned to discover that Robin's Jane Doe stabbing victim is Diana Colville, an old acquaintance he hasn't seen in years.
Meanwhile, Abe attempts to warn Tamara about her dangerous relationship with Walker Coleman, but she refuses to believe Coleman has changed, though she later thanks Abe for his concern.
